Ichiro, Greg Smith and Domtrelle Willis for Manny Ramirez and MAx Sherzer. Good trade?

No I don't think it's that great of a trade. Pretty much cancels eachother out. Sherzer and Smith are about the same right now, Willis is hurt for who knows how long. So it's really between Ichiro and Manny. Depends on what you want, more runs and SB's or more extra base hits and RBI.